What You'll Learn in This Article
8 key topics covered to help you take action.
What Cost Per Lead Is
What Each Platform Counts As A Lead
WhatsApp Enquiries: A Tap Is Not A Chat
Why The Cheapest Lead Can Be The Dearest Customer
How To Judge The Quality Of A Lead
Junk Leads, And Whose Job They Are
Telling Google Which Leads Were Good
What Is A Good Cost Per Lead?
Best Marketing Malaysia
Last month the ads brought eighty enquiries, at a cost for each that looked very reasonable. The order book shows six new customers. Before you ask for more leads at that price, ask what was being counted as one.
Cost per lead, or CPL, is the simplest sum in advertising and the easiest to be fooled by. This guide is for the owner of a Malaysian business whose enquiries arrive as forms, calls and WhatsApp messages. It covers what the ad platforms count as a lead, how to tell a good lead from a cheap one, and how to work out what a lead is worth to you.
What Cost Per Lead Is
Take what you spent on a campaign and divide it by the number of leads it brought. A lead is an enquiry: somebody who has asked you something and left a way to answer. It is not yet a customer. The cost of a paying customer is a different sum, set out in our guide to cost per acquisition.
All the difficulty is in the bottom half of the sum. Change what counts as a lead and the cost changes with it, although nothing in the business has moved.
What Each Platform Counts As A Lead
In Google Ads
In Google Ads the column is not called cost per lead. It is cost per conversion: your total cost divided by the number in the Conversions column. A conversion is an action you chose, and Google's categories for leads include Submit lead form, Book appointment, Sign up, Request quote and Contact. In practice, a lead in a Google Ads account is one of four things.
- A sent form on your website.
- A form inside the ad. A lead form asset lets people submit their details without leaving Google. Collect those leads promptly: Google says it stores them for 60 days and lets you download only the last 30 days.
- A phone call. For calls from the ad, you set a minimum call length, and every call that lasts at least that long is counted. This needs Google forwarding numbers, which Google offers only in certain countries, so check whether your account has them. For a phone number on your mobile site, Google says it can only track the clicks, not the calls themselves.
- A tap on a button, such as the WhatsApp button on your page. Google's page on tracking clicks says the tag records a conversion when a customer clicks the link or button.
One setting changes the count more than any other. Google can count every conversion after a click, or only one. Its advice is to count one for leads, because only one unique lead for each ad click is likely to add value. Yet "every" is the default for actions on a website. Left alone, a visitor who taps your WhatsApp button three times is three leads in the report.
On Facebook And Instagram
Meta's cost per lead is the amount spent divided by leads, and Meta adds that statistical modelling may be used where lead events cannot be measured directly. For ads that open a WhatsApp chat, the nearest count is messaging conversations started: the accounts that messaged your business because of your ad, either for the first time or after at least seven days without contact. For WhatsApp Business it includes only conversations started from clicks on the ad.
So one word covers a completed form, a call of a certain length, a tap and a first message. A CPL from one of them cannot be set beside a CPL from another, and a report that mixes them tells you very little.
WhatsApp Enquiries: A Tap Is Not A Chat
For many businesses here the enquiry is a WhatsApp message, and it is the hardest kind to count honestly.
When the button is on your website, Google sees the tap and nothing after it. Whether a message was typed, sent or answered happens inside WhatsApp, out of the tag's sight. Some people tap and change their minds. Some tap twice. So taps overstate enquiries, and the count in your WhatsApp inbox is the true one.
Google has also begun to put the button into the ad itself. Message assets add a button to a search ad that opens a conversation on the messaging platform you choose, and the setup asks for an active WhatsApp Business number. Google marks the feature as beta and says it may not be available to every account yet. Its page on reporting says message ads are available on Android everywhere, and on iPhones in a list of countries that includes Malaysia.
However the chat begins, two habits close the gap.
- Ask where they found you. One line in the first reply, and write the answer down.
- Label the chat. The WhatsApp Business app lets you label chats, to organise and filter customer conversations. Give each chat one label for its source and one for how far it has got, and the month's tally takes a few minutes.
Why The Cheapest Lead Can Be The Dearest Customer
Here is a month for a swimming school in Kota Kinabalu that runs two campaigns and spends one thousand ringgit on each. Every figure is made up to show the sums, and it could as easily have fallen the other way.
- Ads that open a WhatsApp chat. One hundred chats, so ten ringgit a lead. Forty never answer the school's reply. Forty more live too far away or want a class the school does not run. Twenty are real prospects, and five enrol.
- Search ads that lead to a page with a form. Twenty-five forms, so forty ringgit a lead. Twenty are real prospects, and ten enrol.
By CPL the first campaign is four times better. By the cost of a real prospect the two are level, at fifty ringgit. By the cost of a customer the second is twice as good: one hundred ringgit against two hundred. And somebody at the school had to answer one hundred chats to find the five.
How To Judge The Quality Of A Lead
You do not need software. You need three questions, asked of every lead, and the answers kept beside the campaign it came from.
- Is it real? A person who answers when you reply. Not a wrong number, a supplier selling to you, or somebody looking for a job.
- Is it yours? They want something you sell, in a place you serve.
- Is it ready? The timing and the budget are within reach.
A lead that passes all three is a qualified lead. At the end of the month, count four things for each campaign: the leads, the qualified leads, the customers, and what was spent. Three figures come out of that, and they matter in rising order.
- Cost per lead. What the platform shows you.
- Cost per qualified lead. What the platform cannot know unless you tell it.
- Cost per customer. The one that pays the rent.
A campaign whose leads are cheap and seldom qualify is drawing the wrong people, which is a fault in the targeting or in the wording of the ad. A campaign whose leads qualify and seldom buy has its fault after the enquiry, in the reply or the follow-up. How to follow each enquiry to the end is in our guide to managing a sales pipeline.
Junk Leads, And Whose Job They Are
Google filters invalid traffic, and says it protects you from being charged for it. Its page on invalid leads is frank that this does not stop invalid leads. Most traffic checks happen after the ad is served, it says, so people or bots can still reach your site and submit fake or low quality forms, and real people can leave a false email address or phone number. It calls lead quality a shared responsibility, and lists what the advertiser can do.
- Put reCAPTCHA on your web forms.
- Use double opt-in: send an email with a confirmation link, and count the lead only when the link is clicked.
- Have your developer check on the server that the email address and the phone number are in a valid form before the lead is accepted.
A WhatsApp enquiry has no form to fake. The junk shows itself when you reply, which is another reason to grade leads in the inbox and not in the ad account.
Telling Google Which Leads Were Good
An ad platform bids for more of whatever you count. Count every tap, and it will find you people who tap. Google Ads has two goals for teaching it better. A qualified lead is a lead from Google that you have qualified further in your own records. A converted lead is one that has completed a step you choose, such as a sale. Both are sent back to the account from your own list.
Google's guide to high quality leads says when this is worth doing. The action you bid on should have produced at least 15 conversions in the last 30 days across the account. Ideally it happens within 7 days of the click, and the data is uploaded regularly, ideally every day. Where leads cannot be given different values, Google recommends a target CPA on qualified or converted leads. The same guide says that campaigns aimed at lead goals such as qualified lead, converted lead, book appointment or request quote automatically receive invalid traffic protections built for lead generation.
A business with a handful of qualified leads a month is not there yet. Keep the tally by hand, and use it to decide which campaign deserves the budget. When leads differ greatly in what they are worth, the next step is in our guide to value-based bidding.
What Is A Good Cost Per Lead?
There is no figure to look up, and none of the pages this guide draws on offers one. A lead is worth what a customer leaves you, multiplied by the share of leads that become customers, and that share differs from one campaign to the next.
Go back to the made-up swimming school, and suppose a new pupil leaves it six hundred ringgit. The search campaign turned two leads in five into pupils, so a lead from it is worth two hundred and forty ringgit, and it cost forty. The chat campaign turned one lead in twenty into a pupil, so a lead from it is worth thirty ringgit, and it cost ten. Both pay, by very different margins, and neither could have been judged against a single target. The full sum, from the customer back to the click, is in our guide to a good cost per click.
When Your CPL Rises
The figure is made of two others: what a click costs, divided by the share of clicks that become leads. So when it rises, one of two things has happened, and the account shows which.
- The click got dearer. There is more competition in the auction, or the ads have grown weaker. What sets that price is in our guide to CPC.
- Fewer clicks became leads. The page changed, the offer went stale, the wrong searches crept in, or somebody changed what is counted. What to check, and what to change, is in our guide to improving a Google Ads conversion rate.
Look at the second before the first. It sits inside your own website and your own account.
When It Is Worth Getting Help
An owner can keep this tally with a spreadsheet and the labels in WhatsApp. It becomes a job when there are several campaigns on two platforms, when nobody can say which one the paying customers came from, or when the platform has to be told which leads were good. Building that as one system is what our lead generation service for Malaysian businesses is for.
Google Ads management starts from RM6,400 a month, and a landing page starts from RM4,800. The ad spend is separate, and every price is listed in ringgit. The two channels we would usually start with have pages of their own: Google Ads management and social media marketing.
You should also know that we are a Singapore company, and Singapore is where most of our track record was built. We would rather you read that here than hear it for the first time on a call.
We make two offers on this site. On the Google Search and Meta ads we run: Guaranteed >2X ROI, Or We Keep Working Free. On SEO: Guaranteed SEO Growth On Last Year, Or We Keep Working Free. Each has conditions: the ones for ads are set out on the page where you book a free 30-minute call, and the ones for SEO on our guaranteed SEO page. Bring last month's leads, however rough the list, and we will grade them with you.
Questions Malaysian Owners Ask About CPL
What is the difference between cost per lead and cost per acquisition?
A lead is an enquiry, and an acquisition is a paying customer. CPL stops at the enquiry. Cost per acquisition carries on to the sale and counts every cost on the way.
Can a CPL be too low?
Yes. A very low figure can mean that something easy is being counted, such as a tap or a form sent by accident, or that the campaign is reaching people who enquire freely and seldom buy. Look at the cost of a qualified lead before you celebrate.
Is Best Marketing a Malaysian company?
No. Best Marketing is a Singapore company, registered in Singapore. We work with you over Zoom, and the prices on this site are in ringgit.
