Book The Best Discovery Call Of Your Life (Worth RM2,500)
SEO8 October 202614 min readJim NgBy Jim Ng

White Hat Vs Black Hat SEO: What Google's Spam Policies Say

White hat and black hat are the trade's words, not Google's. See what its spam policies call each tactic, and what happens to a Malaysian site that uses one.

In This Article

What You'll Learn in This Article

8 key topics covered to help you take action.

📌
01

Where Google Draws The Line

💡
02

Black Hat SEO, In Google's Words

🎯
03

What About Grey Hat?

📊
04

Three Ways To Break The Policies Without Meaning To

🔑
05

What Google Says Happens

✅
06

Check Your Own Site In Fifteen Minutes

📈
07

If You Have A Manual Action

⚙️
08

White Hat SEO: What Google Asks For Instead

Best Marketing Malaysia

Two SEO proposals reach you in the same week. One is cheaper, promises the first page within a month and mentions "our own network of blogs". The other is dearer, slower and full of the phrase "white hat". Neither tells you what will actually be done to your website.

White hat and black hat SEO are the trade's shorthand for work inside the rules and work outside them. The rules are not a matter of opinion. Google publishes them, with examples, and says what happens to a site that breaks them. This guide, written for the owner of a Malaysian business, goes through that page, so that you can tell which kind of work you are being sold and check which kind has already been done.

Where Google Draws The Line

Google's Search Essentials have three parts: technical requirements, spam policies and key best practices. The spam policies are the line. Google describes them as the behaviours and tactics that can lead to a page or an entire site being ranked lower or completely omitted from its results.

The policies themselves define spam as techniques used to deceive users or manipulate Google's Search systems into featuring content prominently. The phrases "black hat", "white hat" and "grey hat" appear nowhere on that page. So here is a working translation. Black hat SEO is whatever the spam policies describe. White hat SEO is the rest, and Google's best practices say what the rest should be.

Black Hat SEO, In Google's Words

The page sets out more than a dozen policies. These are the eight a business owner is most likely to be sold, or to inherit from a previous agency.

1. Link Spam

Google's words: creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings. Its examples include buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, and using automated programs or services to create links to your site. What you will be offered under this heading, and how links are earned instead, is in our guide to inbound links and link building.

2. Scaled Content Abuse

Google's words: many pages generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users, no matter how the content is created. Its first example is using generative AI tools to generate many pages without adding value for users. When an agency offers two hundred new pages a month, ask what each page will tell a reader that the one before it did not.

3. Doorway Abuse

Google's words: sites or pages created to rank for specific, similar search queries, which lead users to intermediate pages that are not as useful as the final destination. One of its examples is having multiple domain names or pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page. Thirty pages that differ only in the name of the town, each leading to the same enquiry form, fit that example. A page for a branch you really operate, with its own address, people and services, gives the visitor a destination, and that is the difference the policy turns on.

4. Keyword Stuffing

Google's words: filling a web page with keywords or numbers in an attempt to manipulate rankings. Its examples include blocks of text that list the cities and regions a page is trying to rank for, and repeating the same words so often that it sounds unnatural. The footer that reads "aircond service Puchong, aircond service Subang, aircond service Klang" is the textbook case.

5. Hidden Text And Links

Google's words: placing content on a page in a way solely to manipulate search engines and not to be easily viewable by human visitors. White text on a white background and a font size of zero are both on its list. Content that opens when a visitor taps it is not: Google says accordions, tabs and sliders do not violate the policy.

6. Cloaking And Sneaky Redirects

Cloaking, in Google's words, is presenting different content to users and search engines with the intent to manipulate search rankings and mislead users. A sneaky redirect shows users and search engines different content, or sends users to something unexpected that does not meet their original need. An ordinary redirect is neither. Google lists moving your site to a new address, and consolidating several pages into one, as legitimate reasons to redirect.

7. Scraping

Google's words: taking content from other sites, often through automated means, and hosting it with the purpose of manipulating search rankings. Republishing other sites' content without adding anything original is one of its examples. Copying it and modifying it only slightly is another, which covers the competitor's article with a few words changed.

8. Expired Domain Abuse

Google's words: an expired domain name purchased and repurposed primarily to manipulate search rankings, by hosting content that provides little to no value to users. If the "network of blogs" in a proposal turns out to be bought domains filled with thin articles that link to the agency's clients, it is this policy and the first one together.

The rest of the page covers hacked content, spam posted by a site's own users, thin affiliate pages, misleading functionality, machine-generated traffic, malicious practices such as hijacking a visitor's back button, and third-party pages placed on an established site to borrow its reputation.

What About Grey Hat?

Google's page has no middle category. What it has is a test that returns in policy after policy: what was this done for? Links are spam when created primarily to manipulate rankings. Pages are spam when generated for that primary purpose and not to help users. Hidden text is spam when it is there solely for search engines. So several things that are sold as grey turn out to be plainly allowed, or plainly not.

  • Content written with AI. Google's guidance on generative AI calls it particularly useful for researching a topic and for adding structure to original content. Its next sentence warns that generating many pages without adding value for users may violate the policy on scaled content abuse. The tool is not the test. The value to the reader is.
  • Paid links. Allowed as advertising when the link is labelled sponsored or nofollow. Spam when bought in order to rank.
  • Affiliate pages. Google says not every site in an affiliate programme is a thin affiliate, and that good ones add value.
  • Redirects and folded content. Allowed when they serve the visitor, as policies 5 and 6 say.

Three Ways To Break The Policies Without Meaning To

  • Your agency did it. Google's page on hiring an SEO is blunt: ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire. It adds that if an SEO creates deceptive or misleading content on your behalf, your site could be removed entirely from Google's index.
  • Your site was hacked. Hacked content is one of the policies. Google describes pages added to a site by an intruder, and hidden links or text placed where the owner is unlikely to notice them.
  • Your visitors did it. Spam posted by users is another policy, and Google notes that site owners are often unaware of it. An open comment box that nobody reads is the usual way in. Which label belongs on the links your visitors post is in our guide to outbound links.

What Google Says Happens

The policies page states the consequence in one sentence: sites that violate the policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all. It gets there in two ways.

  • Automatically. Google's guide to its ranking systems says it employs a range of spam detection systems, one of them named SpamBrain, and that they are constantly updated. Nothing appears in your Manual actions report when this happens, because that report is for the second way.
  • By hand. A manual action is applied when a human reviewer at Google has determined that pages on a site do not comply with the spam policies. Google says some or all of that site will not be shown in its results, and that it notifies the owner in Search Console.

Getting back is slow. Google's page on spam updates says changes may help a site improve if its automated systems learn, over a period of months, that the site complies. For bought links it is harsher: when the effect of spammy links is removed, any ranking benefit they had generated is lost and cannot be regained. A site that keeps trying is covered too. Under the heading of policy circumvention, Google says it may take broader action, such as removing more sections of a site from its results.

One caution the other way. Not every fall in position is a punishment. Google's page on core updates says these broad changes, made several times a year, do not target specific sites, and compares the results to a list of favourite restaurants: the ones that move down are not necessarily bad. If your positions fell and both reports in the next section are clean, read how long SEO takes to work before you blame anyone.

Check Your Own Site In Fifteen Minutes

  1. Open the Manual actions report in Search Console. Google says a site with none shows a green tick.
  2. Open the Security issues report. It shows Google's findings if Google has determined that your site was hacked.
  3. Search Google for site:yourdomain.com.my followed by a word that has nothing to do with your business. This is Google's own suggestion for finding injected spam: add commercial or adult keywords unrelated to your site's topic. Any result deserves a look.
  4. Read "Top linking text" in the Links report. Google suggests confirming that the link text is what you expect, and not spammy text.
  5. Ask your agency for two lists: every page it has published on your site, and every link it has placed for you. An agency doing honest work has both to hand.

If Search Console has never been set up for your site, start with our guide to doing an SEO audit.

If You Have A Manual Action

Google's instructions are in the report, and they are the same for every type.

  1. Expand the description to see what the issue is and which pages are affected.
  2. Fix it on every affected page. Google says fixing the issue on just some pages will not earn a partial return to its results.
  3. Make sure Google can reach those pages: no login, and nothing blocking them.
  4. Select Request Review and explain three things: the exact issue, the steps you took, and the outcome.
  5. Wait. Google says most reviews take several days or weeks, that link cases may take longer, and that you should not resubmit while a request is open.

If the fault was there before you bought the site, Google asks you to fix it all the same, and to say so in the request.

White Hat SEO: What Google Asks For Instead

The third part of the Search Essentials is a short list of key best practices. The first four, in Google's order:

  • Create helpful, reliable, people-first content.
  • Use the words people would use to look for your content, and place them where they are prominent: the title, the main heading, alt text and link text.
  • Make your links crawlable, so that Google can find your other pages.
  • Tell people about your site.

That is most of white hat SEO in four lines, and none of it is secret. Each has a guide of its own here: keyword research for the words people use, the on-page elements that matter most for where to put them, and internal linking for the third.

How To Tell Which Kind Your Agency Does

You do not need to read code. Google's page on hiring an SEO lists the warning signs, and an owner can check every one.

  • A promise of first place. Google says no one can promise it, and warns against anyone who claims a special relationship with Google or a "priority submit".
  • Secrecy. Google says to be careful if a company is secretive or will not clearly explain what it intends to do.
  • Talk of link popularity schemes, or of submitting your site to thousands of search engines. Google calls these typically useless exercises.
  • A link back to the agency as a condition. Google's line is that you should never have to link to an SEO.
  • An email out of the blue. Google says to be wary of SEO firms that email you unprompted, and adds that it receives the same emails itself.

Then ask two questions from the same page. Do you follow the Google Search Essentials? And which page of Google's documentation supports this recommendation? More questions to ask before signing are in our guide to the benefits of SEO and their limits.

Where We Stand

Put both questions to us. Every statement about Google in this article is taken from a Google page that the article links to, and that is how we expect to be held to account on your site. What the work covers is on our SEO page for Malaysian businesses, a check of a site you have inherited is described on our SEO audit page, and every price is listed in ringgit. SEO starts from RM8,960 a month.

You should also know that we are a Singapore company, and Singapore is where our own rankings and our client results were earned. It is better that you read it here than hear it first on a call.

On SEO, the offer on this site is Guaranteed SEO Growth On Last Year, Or We Keep Working Free: page-1 keywords or organic clicks, counted in your own Search Console, growing at least 10% by month 3, 30% by month 6 and 60% by month 12 against the same months last year. It has conditions, and they are set out on our guaranteed SEO page. To go through them for your own site, book a free 30-minute call. Bring the proposal you are unsure about, and we will tell you which of Google's policies, if any, it touches.

Questions Malaysian Owners Ask About Black Hat And White Hat SEO

Is black hat SEO illegal?

Google's spam policies are the rules of its search results, not the law of any country. Whether a tactic also breaks the law, as copying another business's content might, is a question for a lawyer and not for this article. Google does act on copying in its own way: it says that when it receives a significant volume of valid copyright removal requests about a site, it can demote that site's other content.

Can a competitor hurt my site by pointing bad links at it?

Google's page on the disavow tool says it works very hard to make sure that actions on third-party sites do not negatively affect a website, and that most sites will not need the tool. When it is the right answer is covered in our comparison of inbound and outbound links.

Does white hat SEO take longer?

Earning takes longer than buying. What a shortcut buys can be taken away, and for links Google says the benefit cannot be regained once it is removed. Work that follows the best practices is slower to show, and it is not at risk from the spam policies.

How do I report a site that is spamming?

The spam policies page links to a form it calls a search quality user report. Google says it uses these reports to improve its spam detection systems. It does not promise to act on the site you name.

Is Best Marketing a Malaysian company?

No. Best Marketing is a Singapore company, registered in Singapore. We work with you over Zoom, and the prices on this site are in ringgit.

Jim Ng

Founder & CEO, Best Marketing

Jim Ng is the founder of Best Marketing, a Singapore digital marketing agency. With over 7 years of experience in SEO, SEM, and growth marketing, Jim has personally overseen campaigns that generated RM163M+ in tracked client revenue for 200+ South East Asian (SEA) businesses across 43+ industries. He is a certified Google Partner, has been featured on CNA, MoneyFM 89.3, and Yahoo Finance, and still personally reviews strategy for every new client. Jim started Best Marketing in 2019 with nothing but 70 cold calls a day and a belief that agencies should be judged by one thing only: whether they make their clients money.

Ready to Turn These Insights Into Revenue for Your Business?

Book a free call and we will show you exactly how to apply these strategies to grow your business.