Book The Best Discovery Call Of Your Life (Worth RM2,500)
SEO8 October 202610 min readJim NgBy Jim Ng

Keyword Cannibalisation: Find It, Fix It Or Leave It Alone

Keyword cannibalisation is two of your own pages answering the same search. See how a Malaysian business finds it in Search Console and decides what to do.

In This Article

What You'll Learn in This Article

8 key topics covered to help you take action.

📌
01

What Keyword Cannibalisation Is

💡
02

When It Is A Fault, And When It Is Not

🎯
03

Four Ways It Happens

📊
04

How To Find It

🔑
05

How To Decide What To Do

✅
06

After The Fix

📈
07

How To Stop It Happening Again

⚙️
08

When It Is Worth Getting Help

Best Marketing Malaysia

Picture a kitchen cabinet maker in Johor Bahru with four pages about what a cabinet costs. There is the service page, a price guide written in 2023, a newer article called "How Much Do Kitchen Cabinets Cost?", and a landing page built for an advertising campaign. Each was a sensible idea on the day it was made. Together they give Google four half-answers to one search, and the page a buyer lands on is often the 2023 one, with the old prices.

The trade calls this keyword cannibalisation. This guide explains what it is, what Google has published that bears on it, how to find it with free tools, and how to choose between merging, separating and leaving alone. It is written for the owner of a Malaysian business whose website has been growing for a few years.

What Keyword Cannibalisation Is

It is two or more pages on the same website answering the same search, so that they compete with each other for it. The word appears on none of the Google pages this guide draws on. It is the trade's name for a real effect, and three things Google has published explain the effect.

  1. Google ranks page by page. Its guide to its ranking systems says they are designed to work on the page level, to understand how to rank individual pages. Every search is a contest between pages, and two of yours can be entered in the same one.
  2. Two of your pages can both be shown, and usually no more. The same guide describes a site diversity system: Google generally will not show more than two listings from the same site in its top results, so that no single site dominates them.
  3. Google itself reads two results as a hint. A site owner asked why two pages from one domain appeared together in the results. Google's published answer was that it is a tell that you have more than one page that can rank well for a query, and it added: "You might want to consolidate those two pages if possible?"

When It Is A Fault, And When It Is Not

Overlap alone is not a fault. Leave it alone in four cases.

  • Both pages sit near the top for the search. You hold two places, which is as many as Google generally gives one site.
  • The pages do different jobs, a guide for people who are learning and a service page for people who are hiring, and each appears for its own kind of search.
  • The search is your own business name, where several of your pages ought to appear.
  • The pages are in different languages. Google says language versions count as duplicates only if the main content is in the same language, so your English page and your Chinese page are not competing.

It is a fault in three.

  • The wrong page shows. A buyer who searched for a price lands on an old article with no way to ask for a quotation.
  • The pages take turns. One appears this week and another the next, and neither settles.
  • Neither page is good enough. What you know is spread thinly across both.

The taking of turns has an ordinary explanation. Google has said that it tries to work out which page is most relevant to what the searcher intends, that this can change over time for the same search, and that a page you never prepared can be the one it shows.

Four Ways It Happens

  • The yearly article. "Hari Raya Hampers 2024", then 2025, then 2026, each at a new address.
  • The article that turned into a sales page. A price guide slowly gathers a contact form and a list of packages, until it is doing the service page's job.
  • The campaign page left open to Google. A landing page built for adverts repeats the service page almost word for word.
  • The same service for every town. One page per town, with only the name changed. That case is dealt with in our guide to website structure.

How To Find It

1. In Search Console

Open the Performance report and find a search that matters to you in the table. Clicking a row filters the report by it. Now open the Pages tab. It lists every page of yours that appeared for that search, with its clicks, impressions and position. One page is normal. Two or more, each with a real share of the impressions, are candidates.

Two notes on reading it. The chart counts by site and the Pages table counts by page, so their totals differ: Google's help says that if two results from the same site appear for one search, they count as a single impression in the chart. And the default view covers the past three months, which is long enough for two pages to have taken turns without ever appearing together.

2. With A site: Search

Search Google for site:yourdomain.com.my kitchen cabinet price, using your own domain and your own search. Google's page on the site: operator says this shows which addresses on a site can show up for the term, though it does not always return every one.

3. On Paper

List your pages in a spreadsheet, and beside each one write the single search it should win. Any search that appears twice is a question to answer. Keep the list, because it is also the cure.

How To Decide What To Do

Ask two questions of each pair. Do the two pages do the same job? And which one would you want a customer to land on?

  • Same job: merge them. Keep the page with more clicks and more links pointing to it. Move across whatever the other one says better, then redirect the other address to it permanently. Google's guide to moving pages says that when you have consolidated content from several pages into one, you can redirect the older addresses to that page, and that permanent redirects do not cause a loss in PageRank. Afterwards, change your own links to point at the page you kept.
  • Different jobs: separate them. Make each page state its job in its title and main heading: "Kitchen Cabinet Prices: What Changes The Cost" for the guide, and "Made To Measure Kitchen Cabinets In Johor Bahru" for the service. Google's guidance on titles asks for distinct text on every page, and notes that one title shared by two pages makes it impossible to tell them apart. Then link the guide to the service page in a sentence.
  • Either way, point your own links at the page you want. Google says that the more links a page has to it within a site, the higher its relative importance on that site. If your menu and your articles all link to the old guide, you have been voting for it.
  • The same content at two addresses: a canonical tag. Google's page on canonical tags is about duplicate or very similar pages, and Google calls the tag a hint, not a rule. It is the wrong tool for two different articles. Duplicate addresses are covered in our guide to URL structure.
  • A page that search should never find: noindex. A landing page made only for adverts can carry a noindex rule. Google says it then drops the page from its results entirely. Use it only on pages you never want found. Google does not recommend noindex as a way of choosing between similar pages, for exactly that reason.
  • The yearly article: one address. Keep one page for the subject, update it every year, and redirect the old years to it. The SEO Starter Guide tells owners to check on what they have published and update it as needed.

One caution. Do not delete pages in bulk in the hope that a smaller site ranks better. Google's list of warning signs includes removing a lot of older content mainly because you believe it will help your rankings by making the site seem fresh. Its answer, in brackets, is: "No, it won't".

After The Fix

Note the date. Google has to crawl both addresses again, and its guide says that on a medium-sized site it can take a few weeks or more for new addresses to replace old ones. Then open the Pages tab for the same search. What you are looking for is one page where there were two, and more clicks on it than either had alone.

How To Stop It Happening Again

  • Keep the spreadsheet. Page, the one search it should win, and its job: to teach or to sell. This is a keyword map, and the method behind it is in our guide to keyword research.
  • Look before you write. If the search is already on the map, improve the page that has it.
  • Update, do not repeat. Next year's article is this year's article with the new facts in it.
  • Decide each campaign page's fate on the day it is built: either it is the service page, or it is kept out of search.
  • Link every new article to the page it supports, so that your own site says which one matters. The check for a single page is step 2 of our on-page SEO checklist.

When It Is Worth Getting Help

Four pages about cabinet prices are an evening's work. Four hundred pages in three languages, written by six people over eight years, are not, and finding the overlaps is part of our SEO audit for Malaysian websites. Deciding which page answers which search, and rewriting them so that they stop competing, is the work of our on-page SEO service.

Two things to know before you call. SEO starts from RM8,960 a month, and every price is listed in ringgit. And we are a Singapore company: Singapore is where our own rankings and our client results were earned.

On SEO, the offer on this site is Guaranteed SEO Growth On Last Year, Or We Keep Working Free: page-1 keywords or organic clicks, counted in your own Search Console, growing at least 10% by month 3, 30% by month 6 and 60% by month 12 against the same months last year. It has conditions, and they are set out on our guaranteed SEO page. To go through them for your own site, book a free 30-minute call. Bring your Search Console login, and we will open the Pages tab on your three most important searches with you.

Questions Malaysian Owners Ask About Keyword Cannibalisation

Is it bad to have two pages ranking for the same search?

Not when both are near the top, or when they do different jobs. It is worth fixing when the wrong page shows, when the two take turns, or when neither does well.

Does Google penalise it?

Nothing on the Google pages cited here describes a penalty for it. The cost is the one described above: the wrong page in front of a buyer, or two weak pages where one strong one could stand.

Should I delete my old blog posts?

Only the ones that are wrong or useless. If an old post has earned visitors or links, fold it into the page you are keeping and redirect its address. Google's own warning is against removing content in bulk to look fresh.

How often should I check?

After every batch of new pages, and once a year as part of the full check described in our guide to doing an SEO audit.

Is Best Marketing a Malaysian company?

No. Best Marketing is a Singapore company, registered in Singapore. We work with you over Zoom, and the prices on this site are in ringgit.

Jim Ng

Founder & CEO, Best Marketing

Jim Ng is the founder of Best Marketing, a Singapore digital marketing agency. With over 7 years of experience in SEO, SEM, and growth marketing, Jim has personally overseen campaigns that generated RM163M+ in tracked client revenue for 200+ South East Asian (SEA) businesses across 43+ industries. He is a certified Google Partner, has been featured on CNA, MoneyFM 89.3, and Yahoo Finance, and still personally reviews strategy for every new client. Jim started Best Marketing in 2019 with nothing but 70 cold calls a day and a belief that agencies should be judged by one thing only: whether they make their clients money.

Ready to Turn These Insights Into Revenue for Your Business?

Book a free call and we will show you exactly how to apply these strategies to grow your business.