Book The Best Discovery Call Of Your Life (Worth RM2,500)
SEM8 October 202612 min readJim NgBy Jim Ng

How To Choose A Google Ads Bidding Strategy, Stage By Stage

Choose a Google Ads bidding strategy by what your account can count. See the four stages, the learning period and what resets it, for Malaysian owners.

In This Article

What You'll Learn in This Article

8 key topics covered to help you take action.

📌
01

The Choice Follows What The Account Can Count

💡
02

Stage One: Nothing You Trust Is Being Counted

🎯
03

Stage Two: Enquiries Are Counted

📊
04

Stage Three: You Know What An Enquiry May Cost

🔑
05

Stage Four: You Can Tell Google What Each Enquiry Is Worth

✅
06

The Learning Period

📈
07

What Sends A Strategy Back To Learning

⚙️
08

Two Tools That Protect What It Has Learned

Best Marketing Malaysia

A new Google Ads account asks for a bidding strategy before it has seen a single click. The setup screen suggests one. A forum suggests another, with a target copied from somebody else's business. Two weeks later little has shown, the target is changed, and the whole thing starts again.

This guide is about the choice. It sets out, for the owner of a Malaysian business, which strategy fits each stage of an account, what Google says each one needs before it can work, what the learning period is, and what sends a strategy back into it. What every strategy is called, and what it aims for, is in our map of Google Ads bidding strategies. This is the route across it.

The Choice Follows What The Account Can Count

Google's page on bidding gives two ways to bid: manual bidding, where you determine what you want to pay, and Smart Bidding, where Google's AI sets the bid at every auction towards an objective you define. Its help page on Smart Bidding names the four strategies in that family, which are Maximise conversions, Target CPA, Maximise conversion value and Target ROAS, and states the condition for all of them: you need to have conversion tracking enabled.

So the question is not which strategy is cleverest. It is what your account can count today. A smart strategy chases whatever is counted as a conversion, and it chases a miscounted one just as hard. That gives four stages, and a test for moving from each to the next.

Stage One: Nothing You Trust Is Being Counted

If the account counts nothing, or counts visits to the contact page, start with a strategy that needs no conversions.

  • Manual CPC. You set the highest bid yourself. Google's bidding page says that if you are not sure how much to start with, you can set a maximum bid, and you will never pay more than that amount for a click.
  • Maximise clicks with a bid limit. Google's page on Maximise clicks says the strategy sets bids to help get as many clicks as possible within your budget, and that a maximum CPC bid limit puts a cap on those bids. It adds a warning: with a limit set too low, the strategy may not be able to do its job.

Use the weeks this buys to repair the counting, with the four checks in our guide to improving a Google Ads conversion rate. Move on when a sent form, a call and a WhatsApp chat are each counted once, and nothing softer is counted at all.

Then wait a little. Google's page on how its bidding learns says that after you set up conversion tracking, you should wait for a few conversion cycles before putting a new bid strategy in place. A conversion cycle is its term for the time it takes a click to become a conversion.

Stage Two: Enquiries Are Counted

Now Google can bid for enquiries. Maximise conversions sets bids to get the most conversions for the campaign while spending your budget. Three things on Google's page are worth knowing before you switch.

  • It spends. The strategy aims to use up the whole of the average daily budget. If the campaign has been spending much less than its budget, Google says the switch could increase spend significantly. Set the budget you mean, with our guide to working out a Google Ads budget.
  • It is "limited by budget" by design. Google says so in those words. The strategy is built to spend the full daily budget, so that label is not a fault.
  • It has no cost in mind. For a specific return, Google points you to Target CPA.

Does a new account have enough history? Google's answer is that Smart Bidding can be turned on without prior data, and that it recommends meeting certain conversion baselines, which differ by strategy and by campaign type. It also says Smart Bidding can learn from all of your campaigns, so a new campaign does not start from nothing.

Stage Three: You Know What An Enquiry May Cost

When your own sum says what an enquiry can cost, give Google the figure. With Target CPA you set the average cost you want for a conversion. Single conversions will land on either side of it.

  • No history is required. Google says advertisers can start using Target CPA with no conversion history.
  • Start from what you have been paying. Where a campaign has a record, the target Google suggests is its average cost for a conversion over the last 30 days, adjusted for conversions still to arrive.
  • A target set too low starves the campaign. Google's warning is that it may cause you to forgo clicks that could have become conversions.
  • Leave the bid limits off. Google does not recommend them with this strategy, because they restrict its bidding.

The target is in the account's unit, a counted conversion, and not in yours, a paying customer. The difference is worked through in our guide to cost per acquisition.

Two notes on the name. Google says that, starting in June 2026, "Maximise conversions with a Target CPA" is being relabelled "Target CPA", with the bidding underneath exactly the same. And from 17 August 2026 it changed how campaigns that are limited by budget behave under a target, which our guide to PPC bidding explains.

Stage Four: You Can Tell Google What Each Enquiry Is Worth

The last pair, Maximise conversion value and Target ROAS, aim at the worth of the conversions and not their number. Google's page on Target ROAS asks for more before you start: values set on the conversions you track, at least 15 conversions in the past 30 days for a Search or Shopping campaign, and ideally a campaign that is already bidding to the same goal with Target CPA. It also says to report the values for 4 weeks, or for one to two conversion cycles if that is longer, before you switch.

Many businesses that sell through enquiries stop at stage three, and that is no failing. The rest of what the value pair needs is in our guide to value-based bidding.

The Learning Period

After a change, a strategy needs time to adjust. Google's page on the learning period says the campaign or portfolio needs some time to calibrate towards the new goal, and that a status of "Learning" may be shown meanwhile. The status is found under Bid strategies in the Tools menu, and hovering over it shows the reason. Google notes that the learning period does not apply to Manual CPC.

How long it lasts depends on three things, by Google's account: the number of conversions, the length of your conversion cycle, and the strategy. It says a strategy can take a few conversion cycles to calibrate, one or two typically, and less where there is plenty of conversion data. Another Google page gives a rounder figure: a standard learning phase of 7 to 14 days.

Take the longer of the two. For a business whose customers enquire within a day or two of clicking, that is the 7 to 14 days. For a slow sale it is the cycles: if a renovation firm in Johor Bahru sees most of its enquiries a fortnight after the click, one or two of its own cycles is two to four weeks.

What to do meanwhile is the easy part. Google's advice is to continue using the account as usual, and to hold off measuring performance until the learning period is over, because key metrics may vary. It adds that the bidding goes on learning after the status has gone.

What Sends A Strategy Back To Learning

The status in your account names three reasons.

  • New strategy. It was recently created, or reactivated.
  • Setting change. A setting of the strategy was changed.
  • Composition change. Campaigns, ad groups or keywords were added to it or removed from it.

Google's reference list for developers has three more: a recent budget change, a change to the conversion types the strategy bids on, and a change to the conversion settings. Read as a list of mistakes, they look like this.

  1. Pausing and restarting. A campaign switched off for the Chinese New Year week and on again is a reactivated strategy.
  2. Dripping in changes. Five keywords on Monday, an ad group on Wednesday, three keywords removed on Friday. Collect the changes and make them together.
  3. Jumping the budget. Doubling it the week before Hari Raya can put the strategy back to learning in the very week you wanted it settled. Raise it earlier, and in steps.
  4. Changing what counts, or how. Adding the WhatsApp button as a new conversion in the middle of a campaign changes what the strategy is aiming at, and so does a change to the conversion settings. Decide both in stage one.
  5. Switching strategy and back. Each switch is a new strategy.

What about changing the target?

Here Google's own pages pull two ways. Its page on how the bidding learns says you should feel comfortable changing CPA and ROAS targets as often as you like and by as much as you like, that changing a target will not trigger a learning status, and that it will not reset anything Smart Bidding has already learned. Its page on conversion actions says to avoid frequent manual changes to budgets, targets or conversion goals during the learning phase, because these adjustments will reset the learning window.

Our reading is the cautious one. In the first weeks of a new strategy, leave all three alone. After that, change a target when your own sum changes, not because of one bad week, and judge the result after one or two conversion cycles, which is the interval Google itself gives.

Two Tools That Protect What It Has Learned

  • Data exclusions. When a website revamp breaks the tag for a week, the strategy sees clicks with no conversions and learns the wrong lesson. Google describes data exclusions as a way to tell Smart Bidding to ignore all data from dates when conversion tracking had issues. It says they are meant for outages or major issues, and that using them often or for long periods could harm performance.
  • Seasonality adjustments. These tell Smart Bidding to expect a change in conversion rate for an upcoming event. Google calls them ideal for short events of 1 to 7 days, and says they may not work as well for periods of more than 14 days. Its page on how the bidding learns adds that in most cases Smart Bidding handles seasonal increases in traffic without any input. Keep the tool for a short sale with a known date.

How To Judge The Strategy You Chose

  • On enough conversions. Google recommends measuring over a longer period that has at least 30 conversions, such as a month or more, and 50 for Target ROAS. A campaign that brings eight enquiries a month needs a quarter, not a week.
  • After the delay. Leave out the most recent days, whose clicks have not finished converting. Google's own example, for a business with a delay of 2 days, reads 28 days of history with the past 2 days excluded.
  • With an experiment, for a big switch. On its page for Target CPA, Google offers "Save as experiment" in place of "Save". It runs an experiment that compares the new settings against the original campaign.
  • By the status. A status of "Limited" names its cause, such as bid limits, budget or too little search volume. Each has a different cure, and only one of them is more money.

Do not change course on a dip. Google lists new keywords, new ad copy, changed landing pages, seasonality and competition among the causes of fluctuation, and asks for at least one conversion cycle before you evaluate.

When It Is Worth Getting Help

An owner can find the stage an account is at in an afternoon. Holding it there is the work: conversions that stay honest, changes made together and not in drips, and somebody who waits out the learning period before judging. That is part of our Google Ads management service in Malaysia, where the ad account stays in your name from the first day.

There are shorter pages on Google Ads for Johor Bahru businesses and Google Ads for Petaling Jaya businesses. Management starts from RM6,400 a month. The ad spend is separate, you pay it to Google directly, and the full price list is in ringgit.

You should also know that we are a Singapore company, and Singapore is where our track record with Google Ads was built. We would rather you read that here than hear it for the first time on a call.

For the Google Search and Meta ads we run, the offer on this site is Guaranteed >2X ROI, Or We Keep Working Free. It has conditions, and they are set out on the page where you book a free 30-minute call. Bring your ad account, and we will tell you which stage each campaign is at and whether its strategy fits.

Questions Malaysian Owners Ask About Choosing A Bidding Strategy

Can a brand new account use Smart Bidding from the first day?

Google allows it. Smart Bidding can be turned on without prior data, and Target CPA can start with no conversion history. The condition that matters is the counting. Until the conversions are ones you trust, stay at stage one.

How long is the learning period?

Typically one or two conversion cycles, by Google's page on the subject, and 7 to 14 days by another of its pages. Count your own cycle, the usual time between a click and an enquiry, and take the longer of the two.

Is manual bidding ever the better choice?

At stage one, yes, and for a campaign with too few conversions to learn from. Manual CPC has no learning period, and its limit is the one you typed. It cannot tell a likely buyer from an unlikely one, which is what the smart strategies are for.

Is Best Marketing a Malaysian company?

No. Best Marketing is a Singapore company, registered in Singapore. We work with you over Zoom, and the prices on this site are in ringgit.

Jim Ng

Founder & CEO, Best Marketing

Jim Ng is the founder of Best Marketing, a Singapore digital marketing agency. With over 7 years of experience in SEO, SEM, and growth marketing, Jim has personally overseen campaigns that generated RM163M+ in tracked client revenue for 200+ South East Asian (SEA) businesses across 43+ industries. He is a certified Google Partner, has been featured on CNA, MoneyFM 89.3, and Yahoo Finance, and still personally reviews strategy for every new client. Jim started Best Marketing in 2019 with nothing but 70 cold calls a day and a belief that agencies should be judged by one thing only: whether they make their clients money.

Ready to Turn These Insights Into Revenue for Your Business?

Book a free call and we will show you exactly how to apply these strategies to grow your business.